Drash: becoming Kin

This message was shared with Congregation Sha’ar Zahav as part of a pulpit exchange between FMCSF and the synagogue from which we rent space.

Genesis 23:1-25:18

It is an honor to share with you this evening. I want to congratulate you on your upcoming 50th anniversary and honor the ways you have been an inspiration and safe haven for so many. Over twenty years ago, when you first welcomed First Mennonite to rent your beautiful worship space, it was significant for us that our congregations share the commitment to LGBTQ inclusion. At that time First Mennonite was facing push back from the broader Mennonite Church. Knowing we were not alone in our commitment to inclusive faith was strengthening. 

Last year our congregation was blessed during our 50th anniversary year to have Rabbi Copeland preach a sermon on the Psalms! We were grateful that she humored us in this way, given it’s not typical drash content.  

Thank you for taking the risk of welcoming Christians into your sanctuary, and for the ways you have been part of our journey of recognizing and undoing Christian anti-semitism in our congregational life. 

Maggid Eli Ramer, a leader here at Sha’ar Zahav, has been a central teacher and guide for us on this path, as a regular participant with First Mennonite. He is often a conversation partner with Sheri and I as we craft our sermons. Rev. Sheri Hostetler has been in pastoral leadership at First Mennonite for over 25 years. A few years ago Eli encouraged us to consider preaching through the bible in a year based on how Jewish people engage with scripture in a narrative way. 

Interestingly, the Christian lectionary, which provides the readings for each Sunday, has a piecemeal rather than narrative approach. 

At the origins of our Mennonite tradition in the 1500s in Europe, the printing press has just been invented. For the first time, commoner Christians were able to read the bible, and our forebearers realized that the priests (both Catholic and Protestant) had been leaving out a lot of content. 

For Mennonites – originally known as Anabaptists – reading scripture together in community was a central tenant of faith. They were called Anabaptists because they re-baptized themselves (which was heretical). They believed that all people could understand and discern the significance of scripture for daily life. 

This led to some major deviations from the status quo of Christendom. They refused to baptize their infants believing that only adults could choose to be Christian. They refused to take up arms and fight for princes or kings because Jesus practiced non-violence. And they refused to pay taxes (called tithes) when they saw that money only benefiting the already-wealthy institutions of Christendom at the expense of the poor. 

To celebrate the 500th anniversary of our tradition – last year – the global Mennonite church released the Anabaptist Community Bible. In the margins of this bible, reflections from over 500 different Mennonites groups are included, as a way of modeling our ongoing commitment to discernment of scripture in community. Kinda like a Mennonite midrash. 

So when Eli encouraged us to read through the bible in a year it felt very much in keeping with our tradition’s commitment to scripture. As a preaching pastor it gave me the opportunity to sink into the story in a way I’m not often able to do. And Eli exhorted us to argue with the text as much as we wanted. 

The first sermon I preached in the series actually encompassed the Torah reading for this service and I titled it “Blessed to be a Blessing.” In reading the text I concluded that Sarah and Abraham were blessed by God not because they were special or better than other peoples. They were blessed so that they could be a blessing to all the families of the earth. 

That truth became a touchpoint for our ongoing bible study. We call it the “original instructions.” The prophets of scripture were always calling the people back to these original instructions – to be a blessing to all the families of the earth. 

In the Torah text, Chaye Sarah, I looked to see where these original instructions might be manifesting. I was struck first by Abraham’s relationship with the Hittites. Upon Sarah’s death he sought a burial site and the people of the land generously accommodated him. They helped him think through what would make sense and ultimately sold him a piece of land. They welcomed him as a stranger to co-exist among them. 

Although texts around property ownership can be interpreted in many different ways, what stands out to me is that the people of land had no qualms about welcoming him to establish his family among them. 

As the American people emphatically expressed this week, it is a blessing to co-exist across our differences. In all parts of this country voters said no to racist, transphobic, white Christian nationalist candidates. I know both of our congregations are active in supporting democracy – whether postcard writing or action planning or serving as poll workers. These are ways we embody what it means to be a blessing to all the families of the earth. 

The other embodiment of the original instructions was illuminated to me by Rabbi David Kasher. He made the case that Abraham’s new wife following Sarah’s death, Keturah, could have actually been Hagar. Rabbi Kasher wrote about this in terms of the “economy of characters” principle, where rabbis of the midrash will fold two characters together who play similar roles.

In Gen. 24:26 Isaac is just returning from Be’er Lahai Ro’i when Rebecca, his soon-to-be spouse, arrives. Be’er Lahai Ro’i was the place where Hagar fled to when she was banished from Abraham’s house the first time. She gave the place its name, meaning “the well of the Living One who sees me.” 

This midrash argues that Isaac actually brought her back to be Abraham’s wife, because he didn’t want his father to be alone after Sarah’s death, and because maybe Abraham never stopped loving Hagar.

In this interpretation of the text Hagar, a foreigner who was banished twice, becomes family. Whether this re-reading of Hagar resonates, the end of the text suggests reconciliation between Isaac and Ismael, as together they bury Abraham. 

As a Christian I’ve never encountered a commentary that wondered about the possibilities of reconciliation between Hagar and Abraham, Isaac and Ismael. Reconciliation is truly a beautiful way to be a blessing to all the families of the earth. And it is really hard especially when power is unequal in relationships, from the personal to the societal. 

As a Christian pastor, I deeply lament the ways that Christians throughout history have been anything BUT a blessing to all the families of the earth. And I am grateful for the ways through interfaith relationships that we are able to reckon with this reality and, day by day, take a different path together. 

May the text continue its inquiry among us – in this time and place, how are we a blessing to all the families of the earth, and how are we missing the mark? Who are the prophets among us – reminding us of these original instructions and inviting us toward healing and reconciliation? May we heed their calls and may we join with others across faith traditions to continue creating the world we so desperately need. Amen

Similar Posts

  • Sermon: Heaven and Hell?

    This sermon was given on “Throwback Sunday,” an annual Sunday where we take a look at problematic theological ideas with which many of us may have grown up. I’m giving this sermon from Walnut Creek, Ohio, where I am visiting my family. This is where I grew up. This was the place that taught me…

  • Sermon: On Impermanence

    This sermon was preached on All Saints Day. Selections from Isaiah 40 We are made from this earth. God took the dust of the ground — adamah in Hebrew — and breathed into it to make us — adam. And one day, we return to it. Ashes to ashes, dust to dust. Our name —…

  • Sermon: Called to be light-bearers

    By Joanna Lawrence Shenk Matthew 2:1-12 We made it! It’s 2021! Finally! I mean it was the strangest New Years Eve ever, but that’s how 2020 rolled. I imagine we rang in the new year in lots of creative ways. For example, I did handstands with some friends over Zoom. With the new year under…

  • Pentecost Sermon: Unthinkable

    Acts 2:1-21 Pentecost is the day when the unthinkable happens. On Pentecost, 120 people sit in an upper room, waiting to be baptized with the Holy Spirit, because Jesus told them this was going to happen. I doubt any of them could have imagined what this meant. And so they wait, in a room that…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *